*Vision 2020 is actively responding to the COVID-19 crisis with resources and events. Please navigate below to “COVID-19 Strategies and Resources” and “Workshops and Events.”
A yearlong Poorvu Center initiative designed to promote effective teaching and learning strategies around challenging content and difficult classroom dialogues by:
Channeling national, campus, and classroom tensions into discussion across difference through venues that promote learning and deep listening;
Curating aligned resources and programs from across Yale University into a visible collection that supports effective, empathetic teaching and learning, and;
Customizing departmental support by facilitating practical workshops that address unique departmental needs.
Vision 2020 Yale Partners:
Learn more below about partnering with us: request a custom program, share or adopt resources, and/or participate in a Vision 2020 program!
Request a Custom Program
Poorvu Center staff design programs tailored to meet the specific needs of Yale schools, departments, units, and classes. Custom programs can include (and are not limited to) a departmental workshop, a conversation with instructors, or a visit to a faculty/staff meeting to address research and best practices. Consider sample programs to learn more.
Poorvu staff are trained in facilitating workshops on a variety of topics. As part of Vision 2020, Poorvu Center staff and partners from across campus will participate in a workshop facilitated by Libby Roderick, director of the University of Alaska’s Difficult Dialogues program, focused on further refining our skills for training others to effectively facilitate classroom conversations about controversial and sensitive topics.
Instructors, students, and teaching center staff at Yale and around the world have designed resources to support difficult dialogues and controversial content in the classroom. Check out our top ten strategies and additional resources below. If you would like to share a resource with us or request something you do not see, please email us.
COVID-19 Strategies and Resources
As we continue to navigate the COVID-19 crisis, there are a variety of practices that instructors and students can adopt and / or encourage with one another in order to maintain mental health and negotiate topics like pandemic, isolation, and death in the classroom. The following strategies may be appropriate at various points in the semester:
- Remember student mental health and broader life situations, particularly during assessment; when responding to individual issues; and at typically stressful points in the semester
- Assume a balanced approach to discussing pandemic (not too much, not too little)
- Review upcoming content for potential intersections with pandemic
- Consider flexible assignments, assessments, and modes of participation
- Check in socially with students
- If tensions arise, ask students to pause conversation and take some time to write privately
- Be proactive: reach out to students exhibiting deeper emotional struggles or contact their Residential College Dean
The following resources provide strategies and approaches that can support student mental health throughout remote learning:
Coping With Coronavirus: How faculty members can support students in traumatic times (Chronicle of Higher Education)
Tips to Help College Students During the COVID-19 Pandemic (McLean Harvard Medical School Affiliate)
How College Students Can Prioritize Mental Health During the COVID-19 Outbreak (The Talkspace Voice)
Taking Care of Your Mental Health in the Face of Uncertainty (Connecticut College)
Managing Inappropriate Comments Remotely (Yale University Poorvu Center)
Finally, the following strategies can easily be adapted to the online environment. For assistance, please submit a consultation request to the Poorvu Center and we’d be delighted to help.
Strategies for Difficult Dialogues at Yale
- Consider the diverse range of potential students a class at Yale might draw
- Review course materials to identify areas with sensitive content and consider resources below for managing this content
- Reflect on the valid, natural role of emotional response in the learning process
- Consider the syllabus and what signals it conveys about dialogue and the nature of classroom relationships
- In difficult moments, remember to pause before responding - reflect quietly, write, and listen to others
- Work to perceive and respond to people as individuals, not only component parts of their fuller identity (like race, orientation, opinion, or experience)
- Remember that emotional response can arise from a variety of sources including evidence and personal histories, and, that the nature of evidence/data varies across disciplines
- Take a few minutes to reflect on a difficult moment and write down your thoughts: Is there more to learn or read? How did you act, and how might you engage differently next time?
- Consider inviting some or all participants to discuss matters outside of class in a comfortable environment
- Consider whether the conversation should be further addressed as a class
More Resources for Managing Difficult Dialogues
Difficult dialogues can help students practice being open to new ideas and different ways of seeing.
“Difficult Conversations in the Classroom,” Dr. Suzanne Young, Yale Poorvu Center for Teaching and Learning
“Teaching Controversial Topics,” Yale Poorvu Center for Teaching and Learning
“Difficult Dialogues,” Vanderbilt Center for Teaching
“Navigating Difficult Moments in the Classroom,” Harvard Bok Center for Teaching and Learning
“Best Practices: Teaching Sensitive Course Content,” University of Minnesota Center for Educational Innovation
Start Talking: A Handbook for Engaging Difficult Dialogues in Higher Education, ed. Kay Landis (posted on Vanderbilt Center for Teaching site)
More Resources for Inclusive Teaching Strategies
Difficult dialogues are most productive in classrooms with clear expectations and obvious dedication to empathy.
“Inclusive Teaching Strategies,” Yale Poorvu Center for Teaching and Learning
“Inclusive Classroom Climate,” Yale Poorvu Center for Teaching and Learning
“Effective Classroom Discussions,” Yale Poorvu Center for Teaching and Learning
“Inclusive Teaching Resources and Strategies,” Michigan Center for Research on Learning and Teaching
“Learning Student Names,” Yale Poorvu Center for Teaching and Learning
“Establishing Classroom Ground Rules,” Washington University in St. Louis Teaching Center
Workshops and Events
We invite you to attend the programs listed below, hosted by Poorvu staff and partners (please note that some events request and / or require registration). New events are added regularly.
Events in this Series
|Teaching in Context: Preparing for Election Week||Thursday, October 29, 2020 - 2:00pm to 3:00pm||Faculty, Graduate & Professional Students, Postdoctoral Fellows||Click here to register or for more information.|
|Teaching in Context: Preparing for Election Week||Friday, October 30, 2020 - 10:00am to 11:00am||Faculty, Graduate & Professional Students, Postdoctoral Fellows||Click here to register or for more information.|
|Teaching in Context: During Election Week||Wednesday, November 4, 2020 - 12:30pm to 1:30pm||Faculty, Graduate & Professional Students, Postdoctoral Fellows||Click here to register or for more information.|
To Find Out More
Past Events in this Series
|Managing Difficult Dialogues in the Classroom||Online via Zoom||Friday, October 2, 2020 - 10:15am to 11:30am|
|Managing Difficult Dialogues in the Classroom||Difficult Classroom Dialogues||Wednesday, August 12, 2020 - 2:15pm to 3:30pm|
|Teaching Through Pandemic||Help Students Focus||Wednesday, April 8, 2020 - 1:00pm to 2:00pm|
|ATW: Difficult Conversations in the Classroom (Race, Ethnicity, and Culture)||ATW: Difficult Conversations in the Classroom (Race, Ethnicity, and Culture)||Wednesday, April 1, 2020 - 5:00pm to 6:30pm|
|ATW: Difficult Conversations in the Classroom (Gender)||ATW: Difficult Conversations in the Classroom (Gender)||Thursday, March 5, 2020 - 5:30pm to 7:00pm|
|Panel Conversation, The Legacy of Lynching: Artistic Confrontations of Racial Terror||Difficult Dialogues||Thursday, February 20, 2020 - 5:00pm to 7:00pm|
|ATW: Teaching First-Generation and Non-Traditional Students||ATW: Teaching First-Generation and Non-Traditional Students||Monday, February 10, 2020 - 5:00pm to 6:30pm|
|Addressing Trauma in the Classroom with Object Based Learning||John Wilson’s Studies for a Lynching Mural||Wednesday, January 29, 2020 - 2:00pm to 4:00pm|