Benefits and Challenges of Attendance Policies
Consistent classroom presence can lead to better academic performance and improved learning outcomes by deepening student engagement and providing critical opportunities to ask questions, seek support, and collaborate with peers (Credé et al., 2010; Dey, 2018; Karnik et al., 2020). Regular attendance can especially benefit students with greater academic needs or who start off with lower performance (Ha et al., 2024). However, rigid or “mandatory” policies can disadvantage some students and shift the focus from meaningful engagement to compliance. When we apply strict attendance policies to a course, this could be to the detriment of students:
- With a disability or chronic illness
- Experiencing depression or anxiety
- With family or caregiver obligations
- With transportation challenges
- Experiencing poverty or food insecurity
- Observing religious holy days
A rigid attendance policy can result in lower grades, a student failing or withdrawing from a course, increased anxiety, or even distrust within the classroom environment (Lofgren, 2025; Lamb et al., 2020). Furthermore, they can remove student autonomy (O’Brien, 2025), hindering their development of metacognition and self-directed learning skills (i.e., “learning to learn”).
How can we, as instructors, communicate an attendance policy that is seen as less of a requirement and more integral to student learning? How can we encourage classroom presence while remaining flexible for unexpected or life emergencies, and provide space for student autonomy while still maintaining clear boundaries?